The crucifixion scene at Golgotha fixes the world’s attention on the suffering of the Son of God, yet the men crucified on either side of Him frame that moment with a contrast so sharp it reads like a parable written in blood. One criminal hurls scorn; the other turns in repentance and is welcomed into paradise that very day (Luke 23:39–43). Between their crosses stands the Lord who “was numbered with the transgressors,” fulfilling Scripture even as He secured salvation for sinners who look to Him in faith (Isaiah 53:12; Mark 15:28).
In a few exchanged sentences the Gospels show humanity reduced to two roads. There is rejection wrapped in mockery that demands rescue on its own terms, and there is repentance that confesses guilt, acknowledges Jesus’ innocence, and pleads for mercy from the crucified King (Luke 23:40–42). The difference does not lie in background or merit—both men are condemned under Roman law—but in the heart’s response to the One whose cross turns judgment into grace (John 3:18; Romans 5:8).
Words: 2758 / Time to read: 15 minutes
Historical and Cultural Background
Crucifixion in the first century was Rome’s most shameful and public penalty, designed not only to execute but to degrade, to pin a body to a post as a warning to the city’s streets (John 19:19–20). The victims were often insurrectionists and bandits—“robbers” in the sense of violent rebels—men who threatened the empire’s order (Mark 15:27). The Scriptures say that Jesus was crucified between two criminals, one on His right and the other on His left, a positioning that made Him appear to passersby as just another offender under Rome’s judgment (Matthew 27:38; Luke 23:33). Yet the inscription above His head announced a different charge and a deeper truth: “Jesus of Nazareth, the King of the Jews,” written in Aramaic, Latin, and Greek so that all could read why He was exposed to the world (John 19:19–22).
The setting was Passover, when Jerusalem swelled with pilgrims remembering God’s deliverance from Egypt, even as the true Passover Lamb shed His blood outside the city gate (John 18:28; 1 Corinthians 5:7; Hebrews 13:12). Roman soldiers divided His garments and cast lots while leaders sneered and crowds jeered, a chorus of derision that fulfilled the psalmist’s words about the righteous sufferer surrounded by mockers (Psalm 22:16–18; Luke 23:34–35). Among the taunts was a demand that He prove Himself by coming down from the cross, a test that inverted the truth, because the Son would prove His kingship not by abandoning the cross but by enduring it to the end (Matthew 27:40–42; John 19:30).
Isaiah had foretold that the Servant would make His grave with the wicked and be numbered with transgressors, bearing the sin of many and making intercession for sinners, language that wraps the thieves into prophecy even while it wraps the world into need (Isaiah 53:9; Isaiah 53:12). The presence of criminals at His side also signals the hinge of redemptive history. The Law had exposed sin and multiplied transgression without giving power to cleanse the conscience, and Israel’s leaders had rejected their Messiah, yet at the very moment of rejection God opened a door of grace that would swing wide to the nations (Romans 3:19–20; John 1:11–12; Ephesians 2:13). The Cross stands at the threshold between ages, as the Old Covenant meets its fulfillment and the blessings of the New Covenant spill forward toward Pentecost when the Spirit would be poured out (Jeremiah 31:31–34; Luke 22:20; Acts 2:16–21).
From a dispensational framing, this is the narrowing point where Israel’s promised King is offered and rejected, where the program for the Church soon commences with the baptism of the Spirit, and where even in that narrow place the gospel reaches an individual Israelite at arm’s length who looks to the King with faith and is saved by grace (Acts 1:6–8; Romans 11:7–12). The geography and the moment are thick with Scripture, and the men on either side become mirrors for every heart that must answer the same King.
Biblical Narrative
All four Gospels place Jesus between two others, but Luke alone records the dialogue that exposes two souls in the last hour of life. Matthew and Mark report that both men joined the chorus of insults at first, showing what scorn can be when it borrows courage from a crowd and clings to pride even under the shadow of death (Matthew 27:44; Mark 15:32). Luke, however, turns the camera closer and lets us hear a change in one of them as the hours lengthen (Luke 23:39–43).
“One of the criminals who hung there hurled insults at him: ‘Aren’t you the Messiah? Save yourself and us!’” The demand is bold but blind, a plea for escape without repentance, the voice of a heart that wants deliverance without a Deliverer (Luke 23:39). The other rebuked him. “Don’t you fear God,” he said, “since you are under the same sentence?” He confesses justice rather than denies guilt, saying, “We are punished justly, for we are getting what our deeds deserve,” and he bears witness to Jesus’ righteousness: “But this man has done nothing wrong” (Luke 23:40–41). The confession echoes what even Pilate had declared three times—that he found no basis for a charge against Jesus—and it harmonizes with Isaiah’s promise of a spotless Servant who would suffer though He committed no violence (Luke 23:4; Luke 23:22; Isaiah 53:9).
Then he prays, not with a formula but with a name and a plea, “Jesus, remember me when you come into your kingdom” (Luke 23:42). The request holds more faith than it first appears. He calls Jesus by name with personal trust, not distant speculation. He speaks of a kingdom while the King hangs dying, trusting that death cannot end the reign He intends to share. He asks to be remembered, not rewarded, throwing himself upon mercy and not merit. He sees beyond the sign above the cross to the reality the sign announces, believing that the crucified is also the enthroned (John 19:19; Psalm 2:6).
Jesus answers quickly and tenderly, cutting through fear with a word that spills light into a dark afternoon: “Truly I tell you, today you will be with me in paradise” (Luke 23:43). The “truly” seals the promise with the King’s authority. The “today” ends delay and silences doubt about the timing of grace. The “with me” makes presence the heart of salvation. The “in paradise” names the blessedness promised to those who overcome, a word the New Testament uses for the place of God’s garden-like rest where the tree of life grows and where the Lord welcomes His own (Revelation 2:7; 2 Corinthians 12:3–4). Before the darkness lifts and the curtain tears, grace has already carried a sinner home on a promise that rests not on works but on the crucified Lord’s word (Luke 23:44–45; Ephesians 2:8–9).
Other details deepen the scene’s theology. Jesus prays, “Father, forgive them, for they do not know what they are doing,” words that might well have pierced the penitent thief’s heart as he watched soldiers gamble and leaders sneer (Luke 23:34). The centurion at the foot of the cross would later confess, “Surely this was a righteous man,” echoing the thief’s verdict and making the hill a courtroom where heaven’s testimony crowds out hell’s lies (Luke 23:47). The Gospel writers refuse to let us treat the thieves as props; they are persons whose words and destinies lay bare the choice every reader must make.
Theological Significance
The conversion of the repentant thief stands as a luminous case study in the doctrine of salvation by grace through faith. He can perform no rituals and cannot step down to right past wrongs. He cannot be baptized into the church nor present offerings at the temple. He brings only his sin and his plea to the Savior, and he receives a promise rooted in Christ’s person and work rather than in any merit of his own (Ephesians 2:8–9; Titus 3:5). Justification comes not by law-keeping, for he has no time and no strength for such, but by trusting the One who bears the curse of the law for us upon the tree (Galatians 3:13; Romans 3:28).
His confession displays the contours of authentic repentance. He fears God and owns the justice of his sentence, abandoning excuses and comparisons. He recognizes Jesus’ innocence, aligning himself with truth even when the crowd denies it. He appeals to the King for mercy, acknowledging Jesus’ authority and future reign when all evidence seems against it (Luke 23:40–42). The order is not mechanical, but the substance reflects the gospel’s call: turn from sin to God and believe in the Lord Jesus, and you will be saved (Acts 20:21; Romans 10:9–10).
The promise “today you will be with me in paradise” also instructs the church on the state of the believer after death. Scripture elsewhere affirms that to be away from the body is to be at home with the Lord, and that departing to be with Christ is better by far, language that rules out soul-sleep and supports the thief’s immediate enjoyment of Christ’s presence (2 Corinthians 5:6–8; Philippians 1:23). Paradise in Luke’s usage harmonizes with Paul’s and John’s, tying the thief’s hope to the same garden-rest and tree-of-life imagery that crowns Revelation’s promises to overcomers (2 Corinthians 12:4; Revelation 2:7). Salvation is not primarily transfer to a place but union with a Person, and Jesus makes that union explicit in the words “with me” (John 14:3).
From a dispensational vantage, the scene also clarifies how God saves in every age without collapsing the distinct economies of His rule. The thief is a Jew condemned under Roman power at the climax of Israel’s rejection of her Messiah, yet he is saved the same way Abraham was—by faith in the God who justifies the ungodly—because grace is the continuum beneath the differing administrations of law and promise (Genesis 15:6; Romans 4:3–5). The Cross does not erase Israel’s future nor dissolve national promises; it secures the covenant blood by which the New Covenant will be applied to Israel in the coming kingdom while, in the meantime, its blessings flow to the church composed of Jews and Gentiles who believe (Jeremiah 31:31–34; Luke 22:20; Romans 11:25–27). The repentant thief thus becomes an early fruit of the grace that will soon be heralded from Jerusalem to the ends of the earth (Luke 24:46–49; Acts 1:8).
Assurance emerges as another doctrinal gem. Jesus does not say “perhaps” or “after a probation,” but “today… with me,” a firmness that grounds the believer’s confidence not in fluctuating feelings but in the Savior’s pledge (John 10:27–29; 1 John 5:13). The certainty rests in Christ’s finished work, signaled moments later when He cries, “It is finished,” declaring the debt canceled and the way open for sinners who trust Him (John 19:30; Colossians 2:13–14). If a man may pass from blasphemy to blessedness within the span of an afternoon because the King spoke, then hope is strong enough to save to the uttermost all who come to God through Him (Hebrews 7:25).
Spiritual Lessons and Application
The hill of crucifixion teaches urgency. The man who believed did so with lungs already laboring and daylight nearly gone. Scripture urges the same promptness upon every conscience, saying, “Now is the time of God’s favor, now is the day of salvation,” because no one owns tomorrow and delay can harden what ought to break (2 Corinthians 6:2; Hebrews 3:13). The penitent thief’s story offers immense comfort to the dying and to those who love them; it offers no license to postpone repentance, because presuming upon a last-hour mercy is itself a form of unbelief (Proverbs 27:1; James 4:13–15). The safe path is the immediate one: turn and live.
His confession also models humility that runs counter to the age. He stops measuring himself against others and stops bargaining for relief on his own terms. He admits, “We are punished justly,” and he yields the verdict to God (Luke 23:41). Such humility is not a mood; it is the posture of a heart that has finally told the truth before the Holy One. Modern discipleship flourishes where that posture remains habitual, because the same grace that saves also trains us to say “No” to ungodliness and “Yes” to the King who loved us and gave Himself for us (Titus 2:11–14; Galatians 2:20).
The exchange invites hope for evangelism. If a man can be brought from curse to confession within earshot of Jesus’ prayer, “Father, forgive them,” then no heart is beyond reach while the gospel is preached and the Spirit is at work (Luke 23:34; John 16:8–11). The church should not grow cynical about those who seem furthest gone. Prisons, hospital rooms, hospice beds, and family gatherings are fields white for harvest, and the promise “everyone who calls on the name of the Lord will be saved” is strong enough for the eleventh hour as surely as for the first (Romans 10:13; Matthew 20:6–9). Love keeps speaking, keeps praying, and keeps hoping, persuaded that the Lord delights to save.
There is a lesson here for sufferers, too. Jesus does not save the thief by removing him from the cross; He saves him on the cross and promises His presence beyond it (Luke 23:43). Many disciples discover the depth of Christ’s companionship not when affliction ends but when grace meets them in it. The crucified King remains Lord in the ward, at the graveside, and in the courtroom, and He grants peace that guards hearts when circumstances do not shift on our timetable (John 16:33; Philippians 4:6–7). The thief teaches us to seek the King Himself rather than only His interventions.
Finally, the two responses warn and woo. One man dies as he lived, hardened and demanding, and his last recorded words are an accusation that the Messiah has failed to meet his terms (Luke 23:39). The other dies with a promise ringing in his ears and a name on his lips, surrendered to a King he cannot see yet loves (Luke 23:42–43; 1 Peter 1:8–9). The cross does not flatter our options; it calls for a verdict. Jesus is either a scandal to be scorned or a Savior to be trusted, and the decisive moment for that choice is always today (1 Corinthians 1:23–24; Hebrews 4:7).
Conclusion
Golgotha is not only the world’s judgment on Jesus; it is God’s judgment of the world, for there the Holy One bears sin, satisfies justice, and opens paradise to sinners who believe. The two thieves crystallize the human response. One man nails his unbelief in place with taunts, and the darkness that falls around the hill closes over him without light (Matthew 27:45). The other, seeing in the crucified a King whose kingdom cannot be killed, asks to be remembered and is promised a place at the King’s side before the sun sets (Luke 23:42–43). The difference is not moral distance but faith; not deeds but the direction of the heart toward the One whose wounds heal and whose word secures.
For readers on this side of the empty tomb, the call is plain. Come to the crucified and risen Christ, confess the truth about your sin and about His righteousness, and entrust yourself to His mercy. The promise that steadied a dying man still stands, because the Savior who spoke it lives and reigns. He remains the resurrection and the life, and whoever believes in Him, though he dies, will live, and whoever lives by believing in Him will never truly die (John 11:25–26). The crosses on either side teach us to hurry, to hope, and to hold to Him whose grace turns last breaths into first sights of paradise.
“Then he said, ‘Jesus, remember me when you come into your kingdom.’ Jesus answered him, ‘Truly I tell you, today you will be with me in paradise.’” (Luke 23:42–43)
All Scripture quoted from:
New International Version (NIV)
Holy Bible, New International Version®, NIV® Copyright ©1973, 1978, 1984, 2011 by Biblica, Inc.® Used by permission. All rights reserved worldwide.