The Parable of the Pharisee and the Tax Collector (Luke 18:9-14)

Jesus tells a short story that unmasks the deepest realities of prayer, pride, and mercy. Two men walk into the same temple at the same hour, but only one walks out right with God (Luke 18:9–14). Luke says Jesus aimed this parable at people who trusted in their own righteousness and looked down on others, which means the story is a mirror for any heart that gravitate toward comparison and self-trust rather than confession and faith (Luke 18:9). The Lord uses the stark contrast of a respected religious man and a despised tax collector to show the path that ends in ruin and the path that ends in peace with God (Luke 18:10–14).

The setting follows Jesus’ teaching on persistent prayer through the story of the persistent widow who kept coming until justice came, a call to faith that does not give up because God is not like an unjust judge and He hears His chosen ones who cry to Him day and night (Luke 18:1–8). Having urged perseverance, Jesus now aims at posture. He shows that prayer without humility can be a performance rather than fellowship, and that a single honest cry can carry a sinner all the way home because God is gracious and near to the contrite in heart (Psalm 34:18; Isaiah 57:15).

Words: 2724 / Time to read: 14 minutes

---

Historical and Cultural Background

In first-century Jerusalem the Pharisees were known for strict devotion to the law and to many traditions that had grown around it. They fasted regularly and tithed with care, even down to small garden produce, practices that set them apart in the eyes of many as models of holiness (Luke 18:12; Matthew 23:23). They were not all hypocrites, but Jesus often confronted their tendency to elevate human rules and to measure holiness by external markers while neglecting justice, mercy, and faithfulness that the law itself required (Matthew 23:23–28; Hosea 6:6). The public prayer life of such men could be public indeed, with visible spots in the temple courts and well-worded prayers that drew attention to the worshiper more than to God, which is why Jesus warned against praying to be seen by others (Matthew 6:5).

Tax collectors stood at the other end of public esteem. They collected tolls for Rome and often enriched themselves by demanding more than what was owed, so they were seen as traitors and sinners who burdened their own people for profit (Luke 19:7; Luke 3:12–13). Many were rich and few were loved. Yet in the days of Jesus tax booths also became places of grace, because the King who calls sinners to follow Him called a tax collector named Levi and ate with his friends, defending His table fellowship by saying that He came to call not the righteous but sinners to repentance (Luke 5:27–32). The pairing of a Pharisee and a tax collector therefore presses every expectation: the man admired by many is exposed, and the man despised by many is received.

The temple itself framed the encounter. Men would ascend to pray at set hours, and the courts provided space for public prayer as well as offerings. It was a place designed for God to draw near to His people and for His people to draw near to Him in truth, with sacrifices and prayers that confessed sin and celebrated mercy (Psalm 65:1–3). The story’s shock is that the man who seemed to belong in that place walks away empty, while the man who could barely lift his eyes finds the blessing that the temple promised to all who sought God with a broken and honest heart (Luke 18:13–14; Psalm 51:17).

Biblical Narrative

“Two men went up to the temple to pray,” Jesus says, “one a Pharisee and the other a tax collector” (Luke 18:10). The Pharisee takes a confident stance and prays about himself, thanking God that he is not like other people—robbers, evildoers, adulterers—or like the tax collector within earshot. He points to his fasting twice a week and his tithing of all he receives, practices that went beyond the letter of the law and, in his mind, set him apart as pure (Luke 18:11–12). The prayer includes God’s name but centers on the speaker’s record, a list that divides the world into clean and unclean and puts the speaker firmly in the clean column.

The tax collector stands at a distance and does not lift his eyes to heaven. He beats his chest, a sign of deep grief, and says only, “God, have mercy on me, a sinner” (Luke 18:13). The words are few because the heart is full. He does not compare himself with anyone, and he does not bargain. He asks for mercy because he knows he needs mercy and because he believes God is merciful, an act of faith that throws itself on the character of God revealed in His word and His ways (Exodus 34:6–7; Psalm 86:5). The man in the back of the court comes with his guilt and leaves it with God, trusting that the Lord can deal with his sin in a way he cannot.

Jesus closes with a verdict. “I tell you that this man, rather than the other, went home justified before God” (Luke 18:14). The religious man who exalted himself walks home still carrying his sin, while the despised man who humbled himself walks home counted right with God. Jesus adds the kingdom principle that runs through Scripture from start to finish: all who exalt themselves will be humbled, and those who humble themselves will be exalted (Luke 18:14; Proverbs 3:34). The judgment belongs to the Lord who sees the heart and weighs the spirit, and He delights to lift the contrite and resist the proud (1 Samuel 16:7; James 4:6).

Theological Significance

At the center of this parable is the doctrine of justification, the gracious act by which God declares a sinner righteous on the basis of faith, not works of the law (Romans 3:23–24; Romans 4:5). Jesus does not give a lecture; He sets two prayers side by side so that the truth is seen in the light of lived posture. The Pharisee trusts his moral record and religious performance, while the tax collector trusts God’s mercy, and only one goes home right with God (Luke 18:11–14). This lines up with the gospel preached by the apostles, who declared that a person is justified by faith apart from works, and that boasting is excluded because salvation is a gift of grace so that no one may boast (Romans 3:28; Ephesians 2:8–9).

The parable also exposes the subtle power of pride in religious settings. Pride can dress itself in prayer and fasting, and it can recite good habits with a spirit that demeans others while congratulating itself. Jesus warns elsewhere that such righteousness can be an empty shell that whitewashes a tomb rather than a living obedience that flows from love for God and neighbor (Matthew 23:27; Matthew 22:37–40). True prayer is God-ward and honest. It does not parade deeds, and it does not rely on comparisons. It asks for mercy and receives mercy, then rises to walk in newness of life because the Lord who forgives also transforms (Psalm 32:1–2; Titus 3:3–7).

Viewed within the progress of revelation, the story brings into focus the spiritual state of many leaders in Israel during Jesus’ ministry and the presence of a humble remnant within the nation. Jesus often rebuked leaders who strained out gnats and swallowed camels, who tithed herbs while neglecting justice and faithfulness, and who loved seats of honor while loading people with heavy burdens (Matthew 23:23–24; Luke 11:46). Yet He also praised hearts like this tax collector’s and like the contrite sinner who washed His feet with tears, declaring that those who are forgiven much love much because they have tasted mercy that lifts shame and sets captives free (Luke 7:44–48; Luke 4:18). The remnant thread runs through the prophets and into the Gospels, showing that God keeps for Himself a people who hear His voice and bow low before Him (Isaiah 10:20–21; John 10:27).

From a dispensational vantage point the parable speaks to Israel’s stewardship and to future days. In Jesus’ time many in leadership trusted in outward observance while refusing the King standing before them, but within Israel there were those who humbled themselves and believed, a pattern that continues until the end of the age when a people will look on the One they pierced and mourn, and God will pour out a spirit of grace and supplication that leads to cleansing and renewal (Zechariah 12:10; Zechariah 13:1). The story’s principle will ring true in the days of distress still to come, when some will cling to self-made righteousness even under judgment while others cry for mercy and are received into the blessings of the coming kingdom at the return of the King (Matthew 24:30–31; Romans 11:26–27). The church in this present age does not replace Israel but bears witness to the same grace, calling people from all nations to come to the Father through the Son by the Spirit on the same terms of humble faith (Acts 13:38–39; Ephesians 2:13–18).

The language of the tax collector’s prayer points to the cross where mercy and justice meet. He begs God to be merciful to him as a sinner, which assumes that sin must be dealt with and not ignored. The gospel announces that God set forth His Son as the place where wrath is turned aside and sinners are received, so that He remains just and the justifier of the one who has faith in Jesus (Romans 3:25–26; 2 Corinthians 5:21). The man in the temple could not see the hill where Jesus would die, but his plea was answered in the sacrifice that would come, and every sinner who makes the same plea today is saved by that same finished work because Christ died for the ungodly and rose for our justification (Romans 5:6–9; Romans 4:25).

Spiritual Lessons and Application

First, the parable calls us to examine our prayers. Do we speak to God about our record, or do we come to God with our need? The Pharisee uses prayer to compare himself with others and to advertise his discipline, a posture that leaves him unchanged and unjustified because he never actually asks for mercy (Luke 18:11–12). The tax collector asks for mercy and receives it at once, because God opposes the proud but gives grace to the humble, and the one who comes to Jesus He will never cast out (Luke 18:13–14; James 4:6; John 6:37). Honest confession is the doorway of life with God, and those who walk through it find forgiveness and cleansing day by day as they keep short accounts with the Father who loves them (1 John 1:9; Psalm 32:5).

Second, the parable warns against the respectable sins of contempt and comparison. The Pharisee’s prayer is filled with the word I and with scorn toward a man he deems beneath him, which reveals how pride turns worship into self-promotion and people into props (Luke 18:11). Jesus teaches that the greatest commands are love for God and love for neighbor, and contempt cannot live in the same room with that love because love does not boast and is not proud (Matthew 22:37–39; 1 Corinthians 13:4–5). If our hearts rehearse the faults of others to feel clean, we have left the path of grace. The remedy is to look again at the cross where the sinless One bore our shame so that we would never again stand over others but beside them as fellow debtors to mercy (Galatians 6:14; Romans 12:3).

Third, this story reshapes how we welcome people into the household of faith. Jesus ate with tax collectors and sinners and faced the grumbling of those who thought holiness meant distance, yet He declared that He came to seek and to save the lost and that heaven rejoices when even one sinner repents (Luke 5:30–32; Luke 19:10; Luke 15:7). Churches that mirror the Father’s heart become places where the broken can be honest and where the proud are gently confronted, because the gospel creates a fellowship of the forgiven that gives grace without lowering truth (Ephesians 4:32; John 8:11). A community that prizes polished performance over humble repentance has drifted from the temple prayer that God accepts, and the cure is to return to the simple cry, “God, have mercy on me, a sinner,” and to welcome all who pray it with us (Luke 18:13; Romans 15:7).

Fourth, the parable steadies those who fear they are too far gone. The man who would not lift his eyes is the one God lifts, because a broken and contrite heart He will not despise (Luke 18:13–14; Psalm 51:17). The promise of the new covenant is that God forgives iniquity and remembers sin no more, and He invites the weary to come and find rest, not by holding up their record but by laying it down and taking Christ’s yoke which is easy and His burden which is light (Jeremiah 31:34; Matthew 11:28–30). If shame has kept you far off, know that the Lord runs to the humble and clothes them with salvation, and He delights to justify the ungodly who trust Him (Luke 15:20–22; Romans 4:5).

Fifth, the parable humbles leaders and teachers who steward truth. Those who stand before others can begin to pray about themselves and forget to plead for mercy, and those who handle Scripture can learn to use it as a measuring rod for others while avoiding its searchlight on their own hearts (Luke 18:11–12; Hebrews 4:12–13). Jesus warns that those given much light are accountable for how they respond, and He calls shepherds to serve eagerly and gently with their eyes on the Chief Shepherd who will appear and reward faithfulness, not self-display (Luke 12:47–48; 1 Peter 5:2–4). The safest posture for every pulpit and platform is the prayer of the man in the back of the court and the joy of one sinner who knows he has been forgiven much (Luke 18:13; Luke 7:47).

Finally, the parable directs our hope to the One who tells it. The temple stood as a place where sinners sought mercy through sacrifice, and Jesus would soon present Himself as the Lamb who takes away the sin of the world so that all who believe might be justified and have peace with God (John 1:29; Romans 5:1). The way home is open because the Son opened it with His blood, and the only people who miss it are those who do not think they need it. The gate is low so that the proud must bow to enter, but it is wide enough for anyone who comes with the simple plea for mercy to pass through into life (Matthew 7:13–14; John 10:9).

Conclusion

A respected man and a despised man stand in the same holy place and speak to the same holy God. One rehearses his goodness and leaves unchanged. The other confesses his sin and leaves justified. Jesus’ verdict does not flatter religious pride and it does not crush repentant hope. It reveals the heart of God who lifts the lowly and resists the proud, who justifies the ungodly through faith in His Son, and who welcomes every sinner who cries out for mercy (Luke 18:14; Romans 3:26). The way into the joy of God is not by standing over others but by bowing low before Him, and those who take that way rise with a clean heart and a new song because grace has done what effort never could (Psalm 40:1–3; Titus 3:5). Let the prayer of the temple become the prayer of our lives, and let the praise of the forgiven become the tone of our homes and churches, until the day we stand in the presence of the King who loved us and gave Himself for us (Galatians 2:20; Jude 24).

“I tell you that this man, rather than the other, went home justified before God. For all those who exalt themselves will be humbled, and those who humble themselves will be exalted.” (Luke 18:14)

---

Want to Go Deeper?
This post draws from my book, The Parables of Jesus: Covert Communication from the King (Grace and Knowledge Series, Book 7), where each parable is explored in its prophetic, dispensational, and theological depth.

Explore the full book on Amazon →